The Black Cat by Edgar Allen Poe


Who but Edgar could take the lovely feline found in so many cozy homes and turn it into a thing of horror? The narrator of  this story relates how he and his wife had several pets (birds, gold-fish, a fine dog, rabbits, a small monkey) but the most beautiful and sagacious was a cat.

This cat, named Pluto, was our narrator’s favorite pet and play-mate. Yet through great intemperance, he seizes it one night and cuts its eye out of the socket. As you can well imagine, the cat avoids him after this, but is unable to avoid its ultimate demise at the hands of its owner who hangs the cat in a nearby garden.

In the middle of the night he and his wife are awakened by a terrible fire. Their home is burned completely, yet the neighbors are entranced by the one remaining wall, the one on which the bedstead rested, which bears the image of a cat upon its freshly laid plaster.

Although the narrator procures a second cat of black, with a white patch ever more resembling the gallows in his mind, there is no rest from the evil which now seems to be taking over. Even the wife is not spared her husband’s guilty wrath, or the influence of a creature out for revenge, whichever way the reader intends to interpret the story. How easy it would be to place the blame of one’s evil actions on an innocent creature, when they can only be placed squarely on our own imperfect nature.

Still, when the leaves turn their edges into golden crispness, and the dusk falls sooner than it did a few weeks ago, it is somehow pleasant to think of black cats…to wonder that if they are wronged, they will somehow cause the truth to prevail.

22 thoughts on “The Black Cat by Edgar Allen Poe

    • Personally, I enjoyed Natsuo Kirino very much. The first book of hers I read was Out, which remains my favorite. I have read others, but I can’t remember what they are right now! 😦 I guess you could see them if you click on her name in my sidebar…


      • A Great Books Foundation discussion group I often attend read this story a couple years ago. I remember being reminded of The Tell-Tale Heart as well. Funny that you read The Black Cat and James read Man-Eating Cats the same week. I love the Deal Me In “coincidences”…. 🙂


        • I have such respect for Great Books discussions! I have been certified by the University if Chicago to teach Jr. Great Books, which is a remarkable way to study literature for the children, but I always long to attend an adult group for myself. I bet they would have a lot to say about this particular story! As for coincidences, isn’t that wonderful?!


          • I particularly like their ‘rules’ for the “method of shared inquiry”, which I try to apply to other book clubs/groups that I participate in as well. This group has been around for years and years and I am the junior member by almost 20 years I think (& I’m no spring chicken myself). I also like that everything we’ve read is pretty high quality stuff, unlike random private book clubs where you take turns reading books each other pick and sometimes have to suffer through a “dud.” 🙂


    • Thanks for telling me about “iPoe”, Stu! You always have so many helpful reading hints. I was amazed when I looked for images of this story how many times it had been made into a film , or a play, or how many arists have rendered their own version of the most salient points. It is a very intriguing story.


  1. Apparently it’s been too long since I visited your blog because I didn’t realize you moved to WP!

    I read this one many years ago and it was absolutely creepy. Although which of his short stories isn’t?!


    • Well, Trish, you were a big part of the reason I switched (back) to WordPress. The frustration with Blogger became too much: no personal support, too many anonymous comments, etc.

      This is a great example of Poe at his creepiest. I wonder how people can be that scared of Stephen King, when to me, Poe is even scarier.


    • I have a tabby which is almost black…I love her so much, I could never see any evil in her. Nor could I ever imagine anyone causing her harm. I’ll bet your black cat is beautiful!


  2. Pingback: Deal Me In – Week 39 Wrap Up | Bibliophilopolis

  3. Pingback: Books Read in 2014 | Dolce Bellezza

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s