Swimming to Elba by Silvia Avallone

I can’t remember when I’ve had a more visceral reaction to a novel. It’s taken me more than a week to read Swimming to Elba because I was soaking in each of the 308 pages, feeling the heat on the cement courtyard of the public housing project where families live in 850 square foot apartments. They empty the water from the pasta pot for lunch, they shout at children, they ignore the needles and the urine which is perfectly normal to see on the public stairways. The men work at the Lucchini Steelworks in Piombino, across from Elba, and in the evening some of them gamble. Or, go to striptease shows at the Gilda. Or, come home and beat their wives or children.

What does it mean to grow up in a complex of four big tenements shedding sections of balconies and chunks of asbestos into a courtyard where little kids play alongside older kids dealing drugs and old people who reek of decay? What kind of vision do you get of the world in a place where it’s normal not to go anywhere on vacation, not to know anything about the world, to never read the newspaper, to never read a book, and that’s just how life is? The two of them, in this place, sought each other out, chose each other. (p. 25)

In the midst of this environment live Anna and Francesca, two thirteen year old girls who have a relationship beyond the closeness one would find in friends. It is almost beyond the relationship one would find in sisters. They are inseparable. They are beautiful. They are unto one another, with a dream, as many other residents who live in Piombino feel, of one day swimming to Elba.

But a divide comes into their friendship, and they separate. Anna begins to date Mattia, her brother’s Alessio’s older friend. Francesca clings to Lisa, the dumpy, unloved one in their community. No longer do the run into the salty sea water, visit their hiding place where the abandoned cats come for a picnic they have brought, or pose in front of mirrors together wearing an excess of make up and a scanty amount of clothing. No longer do they help each other bear the fact that Francesca’s father beats her, and Anna’s father is a hopeless gambler.  Only when a terrible tragedy occurs can they find a solution. Because for them, this sentence is true: “The fact is, you alone aren’t enough for you.”(p.220)

I loved this book.

Silvia Avallone is a published poet who was born in Biella, Italy, in 1984 and now lives in Bologna. This first novel–published in Italy as Acciaio–won second place in the 2010 Strega Prize competition, was a #1 bestseller in Italy, and rights have been sold in twenty languages.

9 thoughts on “Swimming to Elba by Silvia Avallone”

  1. WOW! This sounds amazing — and that you had a such a strong reaction makes it even more appealing. Adding this to the TBR immediately.


  2. I think I can safely say you won't be disappointed, Audra. The setting sounds bleak, which it is, but their relationship transcends all. It's beautiful to see.


  3. i confess the pathos of the book and your visceral reaction were a little hard for me to tune into after you mentioned that they lived in an 850 square foot apartment. That made me laugh out loud – that's more square feet than my apartment, and mine would be perfectly adequate for a family of four.

    Ah, well. Everything is relative of course, and it is true that my property is better kept and less “seedy”. I know that other kind of environment, and it would be the perfect setting for such a novel. I'm interested in this one.


  4. Ah, Linda, here's my Math coming into play again…850 feet means little to me other than the descriptor as part of government housing, and all the cement court yards and pee. Of course I think I would willingly live anywhere in Italy! My husband and I saw bungalows along the Amalfi coast where families of at least four lived in probably 300 square feet for the summer. To me? A dream! I loved the show Big Style, Small Spaces as well as the books on Tiny Houses. So, it isn't the size that matters, it is the depravity of the community which struck me so forcefully. Well, and the writing is gorgeous, too, lest you think I like to dwell on such sad themes. x


  5. And yet another book to add to my “to-buy” list at Goodreads – I actually picked up for a re-read “There Are No Children Here” (forgot to put that on my currently reading list – guess I'll do so after this comment) – and this novel puts that one in mind (although “There Are No Children” is non-fiction, it's still a fasinating insight into a life that many of us know nothing about). I imagine that friendships are so much more precious when everything around you is so difficult.


  6. You've convinced me! And to comment on small abodes, I've lived in large homes, small homes and tiny apartments. Our little 1400 square foot bungalow is my all-time favorite, although I would love a larger kitchen. And bathroom with a large bathtub for soaking. 😉


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s