When I read the book Clementine, Friend of the Week aloud to my class this month it was the first time I’d read a book by Sara Pennypacker. Reminding me of Junie B. Jones (by Barbara Park) and Beezus (of Beverly Cleary fame), Clementine can stand on her own as a precocious little heroine. I was a bit embarrassed when I read that she named the cat Flomax (explain that to eight year olds and hope their parents don’t call you later on), but her antics were ingenious and her sorrow over the (temporary) disappearance of her kitten heartfelt.
Perhaps it would be most helpful to hear the opinions on this children’s book from children themselves. Here are the good, and the bad, reviews from a few of my third graders:
We read Clementine, Friend Of The Week. I thought this book wasn’t that good. I did not like Clementine’s ideas because they were kind of boring. I felt that the pictures were not that creative. I didn’t like that Margaret was acting so weird. I would recommend this book to a friend, but I would rather read Thumbalina. ~Riya
This book was very funny! I thought this book was funny because Clementine comes up with the best bathroom names for her pets, like Flomax. “Moisturizer” (her cat) sounds like a sanitizer. And, I thought the funniest part was the picture that she drew of Moisturizer. I’m looking forward to another Clementine book. ~Vismay
I loved Clementine, Friend of the Week! I liked how she was so funny. I also liked how she was nice and offered decorations to her friends. But I really loved how she never gave up looking for Moisturizer. This book is thrilling. ~Kimberly
We read Clementine, Friend of The Week. I didn’t like the book because it was not interesting, it was not mysterious, or any genre that I like, and it was really boring. ~Karthik
I liked this book! I like the part when she called brother names like Turnip and other vegetable names. I like when her father said, “You are also a friend of the strong.” The last part I liked was when she asked her friends if they would like to use her father’s decorations for the bike rally. I think this book was sensational! ~Aimee
We read Clementine, Friend of The Week. I love this book. I like Clementine because she has whacky ideas. She is very weird because she calls her brother vegetable names. She comes up with names from the bathroom for her pets. She is also very funny. This is a great book. ~Chloe
It appears that the general consensus is in Clementine’s favor. It was a fun book to read and seemed the most popular with the girls in my class. As you might expect.
Special thanks to Disney-Hyperion for the advanced copy to review.
10 thoughts on “Clementine, Friend of The Week”
Now presenting, the future book bloggers of America. Very cute post, Bellezza!
Suko, that's great! What a thought, that I'm raising future book bloggers…and it's true that they love Reader's Workshop as much as I!
My daughter Ellie used Clementine for her food title in the What's in a Name 3 Challenge. Which is incidentally how I found your blog, looking for titles myself. So I particularly liked this post — and I will recommend this new Clementine title to Ellie, with your class' recommendation.
Col, I'll send you my copy. Just email me your mailing address at firstname.lastname@example.org That's so fun how you found me, by the way!
I love Clementine though I haven't read this book yet.I love children's books that can make me laugh out loud.
Very cute reviews, Bellezza. 🙂 I gave my then seven-year-old niece the first Clementine book last Christmas and she read the entire thing that afternoon! Thanks for the review. I may have to get a copy of this one for this year's gift!
Vasilly, the character who makes me laugh out loud is Junie B. Jones, but Clementine gave me quite a few giggles herself. Sometimes it takes an adult, or parental, perspective to get the humour!Les, this would be a good gift for your neice. Sorry I've already sent my copy off, or you could have had it. I'll be on the lookout for other books for her, though. Just prepare her for Flomax. 😉
I have a Clementine fan in my house, and we're excited about this new one!
I'm so glad to see another book in this wonderful series! I recommend it all the time to kids who are ready to move on from Junie B. or who have read all the Ramonas – or who just want a funny, sweet book!
Based on their insightful comments I'd say we have some future book bloggers in your class!