The Winter Classics Challenge Completed

On January 2, 2007, booklogged announced she was hosting the Winter Classics Challenge. In this delightful challenge, one chooses five Classics to complete in January and February. Luckily for me, I was home for all of December and January, and I was able to complete my five Classics before the end of this month. So, here they are in order of completion, the five Classics I read to meet this Challenge:

Dr. Zhivago
by Boris Pasternak was completed in 1956, smuggled out of the Soviet Union in 1957, and first published in Russian in Milan at that time. It wasn’t until 1988 that it became published in the Soviet Union. Its 592 pages tell the story of The Russian Revolution of 1917, and the story of a man ((Zhivago) whose life is slowly destroyed by the violence of the revolution. It won a Nobel Prize for literature in 1958.

I loved this book because no one was left unscathed by the ravages of war; it seemed universally applicable to any culture. I also loved it for adding to my understanding of Russian history, for the beautiful setting in Winter, and for the portrayal of relationships. The movie, with Julie Christie and Omar Shariff, did not do this book justice in my opinion.

A Tale of Two Cities by Charles Dickens is set in between the period of 1775, at the beginning of the American Revolution, and 1789, at the storming of the Bastille in France. It tells the story of Charles Darnay and Sydney Carton, both of whom are in love with Lucie Manette. The story slowly, slowly builds to an astounding conclusion of sacrifice, while weaving in the characters of Lucie’s father and Madame DeFarge who is a female revolutionary with a grudge against the Darney family. The whole time I was reading it my father was saying, “Madame DeFarge, knitting, knitting, knitting…” and looking at me with raised eyebrows and a laugh. It’s opening line, “It was the best of times, it was the worst of times…” remains among the most famous lines in English literature.

This summer, I began working through the Pulitzer Prize winning novels, and California Teacher Guy recommended I read A Bell For Adano by John Hersey. It was first published in 1944, winning the Pulitzer Prize in 1945. It tells the story of the town of Adano, in Sicily, whose 700 year old bell has been taken down and melted for ammunition by the Fascists. The Major who comes to this town, and transforms it into a democracy, is a character I will never forget. He has a heart, does not abide by the rules for rules’ sake, and empowers the people with his laughter, acceptance and courage. This has to be one of my favorite books of all time.

Main Street by Sinclair Lewis was also recommended to me by a friend. (Interestingly, it’s author, Sinclair Lewis, worked at one time as a secretary for John Hersey in the 1930’s.) Sinclair Lewis was not an author I was familiar with, although he may be best known for his novel Babbit. Main Street was first published in 1920, and was Lewis’ first commercial success. It tells the story of small town America in the 20’s through the eyes of a young girl named Carol Kennicott. She comes to the town as a young bride, where she is quite distressed over its dullness. She attempts to transform it into an intellectually stimulating “city” with no success, running into a “wall of bigotry, hypocrisy and complacency” every where she turns. I was personally startled at what I perceived to be her selfishness, leaving her husband to go to Washington for a few years (which reminds me of Anne Tyler’s novel in which the woman is sick of her family and just leaves to begin a new life somewhere else. Who, with any character is able to do that?) and pretending to be more than she really is. Again, this novel is applicable to many places today. Only, I’m trying to get our Now Huge Town small again. But, that would be egotistical of me, wouldn’t it?

Finally, Crime and Punishment by Fyodor Dostoevsky was first published in twelve monthly installments in 1866. Along with Tolstoy’s War and Peace it is considered one of the best known and most influential Russian novels of all time. It tells the story of Raskolnikov, who in many ways reminded me of my brother. Poor, destitute, and filled with little ability to make wise choices, Raskolnikov kills an old woman who is a pawnbroker for her money. Which he never, in fact, uses. Through the course of the novel, he gradually realizes the seriousness of his crime, and he develops a growing need to confess. Against this backdrop, we see him protect his sister from an awful suitor and potentially disastrous marriage. He also falls in love with a prostitute, who, in the end, provides his redemption. (I also counted this as the first of my Chunkster Challenge reads because of its 448 pages. I’m not sure if it’s quite fair to double up like that… )

In conclusion: Classics are my favorite genre. They contain lessons, and people of character which I sorely miss in contemporary fiction. Their length gives me enough time to be fully absorbed in the story, and it’s almost with dread that I finish the last page because I’m so immersed. I found Winter to be the perfect time to curl up with a classic, especially the Russian ones with their setting of snow. So, thank you, booklogged, for this exciting challenge which made me feel I’d really accomplished something during my weeks at home recovering from surgery.

14 thoughts on “The Winter Classics Challenge Completed

  1. Congrats on finishing. You picked some good classics. I listened to A Tale of Two Cities on tape last year and thoroughly enjoyed it. Your comments about Dr Zhivago definitely made me want to add it to my TBR list.


  2. Suziqoregon, I can't imagine listening to A Tale of Two Cities because my aural abilities are not nearly as strong as my visual. I don't think I could keep it all straight, so I'm very impressed with you! I hope you do pick up Dr. Zhivago; I just loved it.


  3. I picked up a A Tale of Two Cities yesterday based on your review, along with Great Expectations. I did a meme that has a list of 100 books posted and those two were on the list. I will start A Tale of Two Cities after I finish Jonathan Strange and Mr Norrell.


  4. ms. teacher, how exciting!! I'm coming to visit your list of books right now, and I hope that you like A Tale of Two Cities once you begin it. Remember, the plot builds slowly, but the ending is a crescendo. I need to read Great Expectations; A Tale of Two Cities is the only Dickens book I've read besides A Christmas Carol (to my embarrassment). How did you feel abouat Jonathan Strange and Mr. Norrell? I thought it was very, very creative, but it sort of began to drag for me near the end. I look forward to talking about Two Cities when you're done.


  5. Congratulations on completing the challenge! I haven't read any of these 5 books (hanging head) but I've had A Tale of Two Cities languishing in the stacks for awhile. I really enjoyed Great Expectations when I read it a couple of years ago. Besides A Christmas Carol, it's the only Dickens I've read, so you're not alone in your embarrassment. 🙂


  6. Congrats on finishing. I am disappointed to say that I will not be completing this one unless I really cheat with the definition. And I was cheating already!!! 😉 This sci fi bug has really gotten ahold of me much stronger than usual and I can't kick it.


  7. Tanabata, if you enjoyed Great Expectations I'm sure that I will too! It's comforting knowing that I'm not alone in having read so little of Dickens. Great Expectations is on my shelf; I just need to pick it up.Carl, are there any sci-fi classics (Dune?) which would qualify? It's good if we can double dip. Wait a minute, maybe that's not fair, as in my last selection where I combined a Chunkster with a Classic (which could also have been combined with TBR books)…What Sci-fi is your all time favorite? 'Cause I've never been bitten…


  8. Congratulations on completeting the challenge, Bellezza! I am so impresssed with your choice of books. I started "A Tale of Two Cities" a while back but it was proving to be a difficult read for me, so I stopped. Perhaps I will try it again either later this year or when booklogged has her next "Classics Challenge". I like what you had to say about "A Bell for Adano" perhaps I'll that pick that up.


  9. bookfool, we share a love of classics AND chunksters I believe! I think Dickens is an author you can't put down and pick up again easily, or at least I can't. I really needed to keep my momentum going with all of these, because the plot is not fast and the characters are involved. Miss Short Attention Span Theater over here would be lost if I laid it down for more than a day or two! Lotus Reads, neither you nor bookfool would be disappointed in A Bell for Adano in my opinion. Also, it isn't long like the others. The Major was a character I so admire!


  10. Great reviews. I enjoyed the Classics Challenge also. I've got a growing list for the next one which includes "A Bell for Adano." But I'm staying away from Dostoevsky.


  11. Framed, ever since I heard Madeleine L'Engle say that her favorite book of all time is Dostoevsky's "The Brother's Karamazov" I've been intrigued. But, I can't read them all in a row. After Crime and Punishment I had to go to a current, pulp thriller like something from Robert Parker. I've read so many of his mysteries that when I picked up Thin Air tonight in the library (from 1995) I can't even remember if I've read this one or not!I think you will love A Bell for Adano.


  12. Congrats on finishing. I finished mine right at the wire but haven't done my final post.I love Steinbeck but never read Bell. I'll have to put it on my future list. You picked some inspiring classics.Good work.


  13. Nabeel, I'm glad you came back to visit me! Yes, there were actually two Dr. Zhivago movies. The first was with Omar Shariff and Julie Christie from the 1960s; the second was with Kiera Knightly within the past few years. Also, I've heard it's going to be made into a Broadway performance, so you may want to read it. Or, not. I just always like the book better than the movie/play. Except for Eragon.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s